Giving circles let you pool money with other donors, study community needs, and share grant decisions. Your individual gift joins a larger fund, giving you more reach and a direct role in deciding which nonprofit work receives support.
This guide explains why collective philanthropy is growing, what the leading research actually measures, and how the model affects donors and nonprofits. You will also see where giving circles fall short, how tax treatment works, and what to verify before joining or starting one.
What Is a Giving Circle and How Does It Work?
A giving circle is a group whose members contribute money, learn about causes or organizations, and decide together where the pooled funds will go. The defining feature is shared grantmaking: members do more than donate to a campaign chosen by someone else.
The process can be informal or highly organized. A few friends may meet quarterly and select one local charity, or hundreds of members may use committees, application rubrics, site visits, and a formal vote. Philanthropy Together describes collective giving as people discussing issues they care about and deciding together where to give money, time, and talents.
Most circles follow the same operating sequence. Members gather around shared values, discuss priorities, review potential recipients, make a decision, distribute the grant, and remain engaged through learning or volunteering. The group may work independently, use a community foundation as a fiscal host, or maintain a donor-advised fund with a qualified charity.

The graphic captures the mechanics, but it does not settle questions about governance. A strong circle documents who can vote, how conflicts are disclosed, what evidence members will review, how recipients are notified, and how the group will handle disagreements. Those rules matter because pooling money also pools decision-making power.
Why Are Giving Circles Growing?
Giving circles are growing because they make philanthropy social, practical, and easier to enter. You do not need a private foundation or a very large gift to take part in grant decisions; you need a contribution you can sustain and a willingness to learn with other members.
The In Abundance study estimated that nearly 4,000 U.S. collective giving groups engaged about 370,000 people and mobilized more than $3.1 billion from 2017 through 2023. A later 2026 Johnson Center report repeated those estimates and traced the support systems that help groups survive beyond their founders.
Several features explain the appeal:
- Shared leverage: smaller contributions become a grant large enough to matter to a nonprofit.
- Donor education: members learn how nonprofits are funded, governed, and evaluated.
- Local access: groups can identify organizations that rarely reach national funders.
- Belonging: meetings turn giving into a repeated community practice instead of a private transaction.
- Visible agency: members can see how their questions, votes, and relationships shape the final grant.
Sara Lomelin, the chief executive of Philanthropy Together, presented the model to a broad audience in her 2022 TED talk. Her central argument is that collective giving can shift philanthropy from an activity associated with wealth to a practice available to ordinary community members.
“Giving by, for, and with the communities we represent is the future of philanthropy.”
Sara Lomelin, TED2022
That claim is an aspiration, not a guaranteed outcome. A circle widens participation only when its contribution level, meeting schedule, language, location, and voting rules allow the intended community to join. A group can reproduce familiar donor hierarchies if a small leadership team controls the agenda or if membership costs exclude residents closest to the funded issues.
How Much Money Are Giving Circles Moving?
The movement has expanded sharply, but the headline figures require careful reading. The 2017 study estimated 1,600 groups, more than 150,000 participants, and $1.29 billion in cumulative giving since those groups began. The 2024 study estimated nearly 4,000 groups, about 370,000 participants, and more than $3.1 billion mobilized during 2017–2023.
Those dollar figures cover different periods, so they should not be treated as points on one annual revenue line. The group and participant counts also came from separate research efforts. The newer study used opt-in surveys because no complete U.S. registry of giving circles exists; it received 543 group-leader responses and 1,406 member responses, supported by interviews and focus groups.
Takeaway: estimated participation and group counts rose by more than 140%, yet the underlying studies used different methods. Read the bars as evidence of major expansion, not a precise annual growth series.
Data as of 2023. Sources: In Abundance (2024) and Rooted in Community (2026).
The scale is meaningful, yet it remains small beside total U.S. charitable giving. Giving USA estimated $617.20 billion in donations to U.S. charities during 2025 alone. Giving circles matter less because they dominate charitable dollars and more because they give many participants a structured role in selecting recipients.
The Raikes Foundation post below highlights findings from Philanthropy Together’s collective-giving research. The social post is useful as public communication; the linked research report, not the post itself, remains the evidence for the figures.
Who Leads Giving Circles, and Where Does the Money Go?
Women lead much of the U.S. giving-circle field. The 2024 study reported that 84% of surveyed groups had memberships that were more than half women, and 60% were composed entirely of women. The figure describes the surveyed field; it does not mean every model is women-only.
The funding patterns are also strongly local. The study reported that 93% of groups drew members from a single locale or state, 70% kept their funding in their home state, and 47% granted within the same city, town, or county. It also found that 83% prioritized organizations serving marginalized communities and 55% supported organizations with annual budgets below $1 million.
Local focus can improve access to neighborhood knowledge. Members may hear directly from nonprofit leaders, recognize gaps that national funders overlook, and support organizations without large development teams. Local familiarity can also create blind spots. Personal networks may crowd out unfamiliar groups, and informal due diligence can favor polished presenters rather than the organizations producing the strongest results.
A circle should ask who defines the need, who can nominate applicants, whose evidence counts, and whether people affected by the issue have a real voice. When community representatives serve as paid advisers or voting members, the group can reduce the distance between donor assumptions and lived experience.

What Changes for Nonprofits When Donors Decide Together?
A giving circle can give a nonprofit money, visibility, volunteer connections, and a group of informed advocates. It can also create a demanding application process for a relatively small award. The value depends on grant size, restrictions, reporting duties, decision timing, and the quality of the relationship.
The best version reduces burdens. Members accept a short application, pay attention to existing public information, compensate community advisers, offer general operating support, and request reporting proportionate to the grant. The worst version asks a small nonprofit to educate dozens of members, host repeated visits, produce custom data, and compete in a public vote without knowing the odds.
Washington Women’s Foundation’s 2026 grant design shows how a mature collective can alter its process. Its advocacy, direct-service, and place-based grants commit $50,000 a year for three years, and its grassroots program targets organizations with budgets at or below $500,000. Members join grant committees, and local experts take part in place-based decisions.
For nonprofit leaders, the right response is selective engagement. Ask for the award amount, number of applicants, funding restrictions, decision calendar, reporting requirements, and whether the circle has funded similar organizations. A warm introduction to one member should not replace a clear and fair process.
Philanthropy Together’s nonprofit-focused webinar offers practical guidance on how organizations can work with collective funders without treating every circle as identical.
What Do Real Giving Circles Look Like?
Real giving circles vary in contribution level, membership, subject area, grant size, and voting method. Two groups can share the same basic idea and produce very different donor and nonprofit experiences.
Impact100: A Replicable High-Contribution Model
Impact100 organizes local chapters around a recognizable formula: members pool contributions and award grants of $100,000 or more. Chapters unite women in a defined community, review local proposals, and vote on grants. The model offers a clear promise to members and recipients, but the usual $1,000 contribution can limit who participates unless a chapter provides installment plans, sponsored memberships, or another access mechanism.
Its strength is focus. Members know the approximate grant size before the cycle begins, and nonprofits know the opportunity can finance a major project. The tradeoff is that a large, competitive grant may encourage project proposals when unrestricted operating support would better serve the organization.
Asian Women Giving Circle: Identity, Arts, and Local Risk-Taking
The Asian Women Giving Circle is an all-volunteer New York City group that funds projects led by Asian American women, artists, and community groups. Its site reports more than $1 million granted since 2006 and identifies the circle as a donor-advised fund of the Ms. Foundation for Women.
Its 2025 public announcement awarded $88,000 to 11 projects, or $8,000 per project. The grants show another use of collective philanthropy: funding emerging cultural work that may sit outside the priorities of larger institutions. The group’s public materials state that it invests in emerging change makers and treats arts and culture as tools for social change.
These cases do not prove that one model is superior. They show the choices every circle must make: broad membership or a defined identity, large awards or more recipients, project funding or general support, annual voting or multi-year commitments, and member control or deeper community authority.
Do Giving Circles Truly Democratize Philanthropy?
Giving circles can democratize grantmaking, but participation alone does not guarantee equal power. The model creates a place where members practice research, discussion, voting, and shared responsibility. The quality of that practice depends on who joins, who speaks, and how the group responds when members disagree.
A 2021 academic study of U.S. and U.K. circles found positive links between deeper participation and several forms of civic engagement. In the U.S. sample, 64% said circle membership increased their participation in efforts to address community problems. Only 34% reported increased involvement in changing government policy, and the author warned that giving circles may attract people who were already active.
The distinction matters. A circle may build donor knowledge and local volunteering without changing public policy or the deeper causes of a social problem. It may fund excellent direct services while leaving public systems untouched. Members should state whether their goal is relief, community capacity, cultural work, policy change, or a mix, then choose grant criteria that match that aim.
The 2024 national study also has limits. It relied on opt-in, non-random surveys because no master list of groups or members exists. Its 543 group responses and 1,406 member responses supply the best large national picture available, but they cannot prove that every U.S. giving circle shares the same demographics or practices.
A practical test is to review the circle’s power map. Who sets priorities? Who screens applications? Who can veto a grant? Are nonprofit leaders asked to contribute unpaid labor? Are community advisers compensated? Does the group publish criteria and decisions? These questions reveal more than the label “democratic.”
Are Giving-Circle Donations Tax-Deductible?
A contribution may be tax-deductible when it is made to a qualified charitable organization or through a qualified fiscal host. A payment sent to an informal group, an individual, or a private bank account does not become deductible merely because members plan to use it for charity.
The IRS states that gifts to individuals are not deductible and that only qualified organizations can receive tax-deductible contributions. Donors must also keep appropriate records. Your eligibility to claim a deduction depends on current tax rules, your filing position, the recipient, and the documentation you receive.
Many circles use a community foundation, public charity, or donor-advised fund. Under IRS rules for donor-advised funds, the sponsoring charity has legal control after the contribution; donors retain advisory privileges over distributions and investments. The word “advisory” is important: a circle can recommend grants, but the sponsor must retain final legal authority.
Before paying, verify the legal recipient, receipt process, fees, grant restrictions, and the point at which your contribution becomes irrevocable. Ask whether the host can support grants to unincorporated groups through fiscal sponsorship and what due diligence it requires. Seek tax advice for your own circumstances rather than relying on a circle’s general marketing language.
How Do You Start or Join a Giving Circle?
Start with purpose and operating choices, not a logo or fundraising target. A circle lasts when members agree on what they are trying to change, how much work they can sustain, and which decisions belong to the group.
- Define the purpose. Choose a place, issue, population, or set of values narrow enough to guide decisions.
- Set an accessible contribution. Decide whether members give the same amount, select from tiers, pay in installments, or receive sponsored memberships.
- Choose the decision method. Use consensus, ranked voting, majority voting, delegated committees, or a documented combination.
- Select a legal and financial home. Compare an informal group, a fiscal sponsor, a community foundation fund, and a donor-advised fund.
- Design proportionate review. Match the application, meetings, and reporting to the size and risk of the grant.
- Address conflicts and privacy. Require disclosure when members have financial, family, board, or close personal ties to applicants.
- Plan leadership renewal. Rotate roles, store records, document deadlines, and prevent one founder from holding all operational knowledge.
- Review the first cycle. Ask members and recipients what consumed time, what improved decisions, and what should change.
When joining an existing circle, request its contribution schedule, member agreement, grant history, fees, meeting expectations, and conflict policy. Read past recipient lists to see whether the group’s actual funding matches its stated values. Ask how nonprofit and community feedback changes the process.
Administrative support becomes more valuable as money and membership grow. The 2026 infrastructure study reported that 42% of groups used community foundations as hosts, 24% used technology platforms, and 24% operated without a third party. Less than half received paid staff support, which helps explain why leadership continuity and compliance can become difficult.
A host is not only a payment processor. The right partner can issue receipts, review recipient eligibility, keep records, support grant agreements, and guide leadership transitions. The wrong partner can impose fees or rules that do not fit the circle. Compare services in writing before members transfer funds.
How Should Nonprofits Work With Giving Circles?
Treat a giving circle as a distinct funder with real people behind the process, not as a miniature foundation. Learn the group’s membership, issue focus, grant size, geography, calendar, decision rules, and past awards before investing staff time.
A strong first contact is brief and specific. Explain the need, the people served, the amount requested, what the money will support, and what evidence you already collect. Do not redesign a proven program around a circle’s interests unless the funding and relationship justify the change.
Ask whether the award is restricted, whether it can cover staff and overhead, how many finalists will present, and whether the group expects volunteer access or public storytelling. Protect the privacy and dignity of the people you serve. A donor-learning event does not justify turning clients into unpaid evidence.
After a grant, offer an update that matches the agreement and shows what changed, what did not, and what the organization learned. Invite deeper involvement only when it helps the mission. A circle can become a valuable network of donors and advocates, but the nonprofit—not the funder—should define where volunteers add value.
How Does a Giving Circle Work?
- Members pool donations.
- They learn about community needs.
- They review possible recipients.
- They vote or reach consensus.
- A qualified host distributes grants when tax deductibility is required.
What Makes Collective Giving Worth Your Time?
Giving circles are most useful when they combine pooled money with disciplined learning, fair decisions, and respect for nonprofit capacity. Join or build one only after verifying who holds the funds, who holds the power, what participation costs, and how recipients experience the process; those details determine whether collective philanthropy becomes shared civic practice or merely group-based donating.
References
- In Abundance (2024 research report) — Dorothy A. Johnson Center for Philanthropy and Philanthropy Together, April 2024.
- Rooted in Community: The Infrastructure Powering Collective Giving — Dorothy A. Johnson Center for Philanthropy, February 2026.
- Growing the Collective Giving Movement — Philanthropy Together, accessed July 30, 2026.
- Schools of Democracy? Giving Circles and the Civic and Political Participation of Collaborative Philanthropists — Angela M. Eikenberry, Springer, 2021.
- Giving USA: U.S. Charitable Giving Rose to $617.20 Billion in 2025 — Giving USA Foundation, 2026.
- Impact100 Global — official organization site, accessed July 30, 2026.
- Asian Women Giving Circle — official organization site, accessed July 30, 2026.
- Collective Grants — Washington Women’s Foundation, 2026.
- Donor-Advised Funds — Internal Revenue Service, updated June 28, 2026.
- Topic No. 506, Charitable Contributions — Internal Revenue Service, updated June 11, 2026.
- Publication 526 (2025), Charitable Contributions — Internal Revenue Service, 2026.
- Your Invitation to Disrupt Philanthropy — Sara Lomelin, TED2022, published September 20, 2022.
- How to Raise With Collective Giving: Harnessing the Power of Giving Circles — Philanthropy Together, YouTube.
- Key Insights From the Collective Giving Landscape Report — Raikes Foundation, X, May 21, 2024.
- Giving Circles Have Exploded in Popularity — Raikes Foundation, X, May 1, 2024.
- Giving Circles Explained — Philanthropy Together, October 15, 2020, CC BY-SA 4.0.
- Group of People Sitting in a Circle Talking — Jonathan D. Mallory / BLM Utah, June 26, 2023, U.S. public domain.
